← All case files
On the recordSystem-wide · since Aug 2024

Clinician-reviewed scribe

Kaiser Permanente and the AI that writes the note, not the diagnosis

Kaiser Permanente · Healthcare · United States

Kaiser’s Northern California doctors used an ambient AI scribe in more than 2.5 million visits and saved an estimated 16,000 hours of documentation, according to a peer-reviewed evaluation. The tool drafts; the doctor edits and signs. The gains are real but modest per visit — and an independent trial elsewhere found them smaller still.

2.58M

patient encounters, Oct 2023–Dec 2024

~16,000

hours of documentation saved (estimated)

7,260

physicians used it; 3,447 in 100+ visits

Ambient drafting, with physician review before sign-off.

Large aggregate savings, built from small ones per visit.

The record

  • Between October 2023 and December 2024, 7,260 physicians in The Permanente Medical Group used an ambient AI scribe across 2,576,627 patient encounters, saving an estimated nearly 16,000 hours of documentation, according to an evaluation published in NEJM Catalyst. (Kaiser Permanente Division of Research, Apr 2025)
  • Kaiser made Abridge’s ambient documentation tool available across its 40 hospitals and more than 600 medical offices in August 2024, after assessments by more than a thousand clinicians; patient consent is required and clinicians review notes before they enter the record. (Healthcare Dive, Aug 2024)
  • A separate randomised trial of 238 physicians at UCLA Health found one scribe cut note-writing time by 9.5% more than usual care, while another showed no significant difference; physicians reported occasional clinically significant inaccuracies. (UCLA Health / NEJM AI, Nov 2025)

A narrow job with a human signature

Documentation is one of the most cited causes of physician burnout, and it is a task with a clear boundary: turn a conversation into a structured clinical note. The Permanente Medical Group, Kaiser’s Northern California physician group, piloted an ambient scribe in 2023 that listens to the visit, with patients informed, and drafts the note. Doctors review and edit the draft, and the tool makes no decisions or recommendations about care (KP Division of Research, Apr 2025).

In August 2024 Kaiser extended Abridge’s ambient tool to its 40 hospitals and more than 600 medical offices, after testing and quality checks that included assessments by more than a thousand clinicians, and with patient consent required (Healthcare Dive, Aug 2024). The scope was deliberately narrow. The AI owns the first draft of the paperwork and nothing clinical; the signature, and the responsibility, stay with the physician.

What 2.5 million visits showed

The evaluation, published in NEJM Catalyst, tracked 7,260 physicians across 2,576,627 encounters over 14 months and estimated nearly 16,000 hours of documentation saved (KP Division of Research, Apr 2025). A review of 35 AI-generated transcripts scored an average of 48 out of 50 on measures including accuracy and succinctness. In a survey of 102 adult and family medicine physicians, 88% said the scribe had a positive effect on their interactions with patients.

Patients noticed, too: 47% of 118 surveyed thought their doctor looked at the computer screen less, and 8% reported some discomfort with the technology. The benefits concentrated among heavy users — 3,447 physicians used the scribe in at least 100 encounters — as the lead author noted: “The users who benefitted the most were also the highest volume users of the technology” (KP Division of Research, Apr 2025).

Small per visit, real in aggregate

The headline total needs a denominator. Spread across all 2.5 million encounters, 16,000 hours works out at roughly 22 seconds per visit — our arithmetic, not the authors’ — although savings were concentrated among heavy users. The value is less a dramatic cut in working time than a change in where the doctor looks during the consultation, which is what the physicians and patients in Kaiser’s surveys emphasised.

Independent evidence points the same way, but smaller. A randomised trial at UCLA Health found one ambient tool reduced note-writing time by 9.5% more than usual care and another made no significant difference; physicians reported occasional clinically significant inaccuracies, and there was one mild patient-safety event (UCLA Health, Nov 2025). “This technology requires active physician oversight, not passive acceptance,” said one of its authors.

The lesson

It worked because the AI was given a bounded, low-risk task — drafting paperwork, not making clinical calls — with patient consent, mandatory clinician review and a published evaluation at scale. Ambient AI earns its place by giving attention back to the patient, not by taking the professional out of the loop.

How we’re reading this

Kaiser’s evaluation is observational and conducted by its own researchers; time savings are estimated, and the survey samples (102 physicians, 118 patients) are small. Kaiser’s venture arm is reported to be an investor in Abridge. The only randomised trial we cite — UCLA, two months, one centre, different vendors — found modest effects and occasional significant errors. We are not claiming better clinical outcomes or cost savings, which neither study measured.

Sources

  1. 01
    AI-assisted notetaking gains steady support from Kaiser Permanente physicians

    Kaiser Permanente Division of Research · Apr 1, 2025

  2. 02
  3. 03
  4. 04
The pattern, anonymizedGood automation, bad automation

Compiled from public filings, court records, company statements and reputable press. Figures are attributed to their sources; allegations are labeled as such. Not legal or investment advice.